Here’s what some of the key players say about the recent NY Court (non-sailors’) ruling, knocking down BMW/ORACLE’s Larry Ellison and propping up Alinghi’s Enesto Bertarelli. As noted below, the paper Spanish yacht club is back in as the so-called Challenger of Record (you’ve heard of Man Without a Country, this is Club Without Any Boats….). Anyway….
Alinghi’s Skipper Brad Butterworth (four-time America’s Cup winning Tactician/Skipper) is reported to have said in Adonnante.com:
“The Cup (AC32) was not too bad and we did amend the protocol 14 times between 2003 and 2007 to achieve this.” In essence, the protocol represents the “sailing rules” for the Cup events and evolves as the Challengers of Record propose changes to the Defender and they are accepted or modified. “…Many of us thought that the first protocol was a bit harsh, however we did correct it and the modified documents was eventually signed by all the potential challengers at the time except GGY/BMWOracle.”
“With the new, bigger boats and cost cutting measure in place, I believe we were heading in the right direction to make the next America’s Cup one of the greatest sporting shows on earth.”
He noted that Sir Keith Mills of England’s TeamOrigin has volunteered to serve as a mediator between Alinghi and BMW/Oracle.
He anticipates the NY Court of Appeals taking six months to make its decision regarding the BMW/Oracle appeal to the recent successful Alinghi appeal of the lower court’s ruling. Then you add 10 months as a Deed of Gift requirement before holding a regatta. Think Summer 2010, perhaps. If the new America’s Cup 90-footers are used, it’ll be only 18 months after everyone agrees to this Alinghi-proposed Jumbo Cup boat.
Here’s how Russell Coutts (BMW/Oracle’s Hired Gun) interprets the recent decision, in a SailWorld.com interview: Surprise, he disagreed with the recent decision, which overturned BMW/Oracle’s appeal throwing out the Spanish “club.” The decision could be “disastrous” for the future of the America’s Cup. He hinted the Americans may be a part of the Cup event at all.
“If Alinghi gets away with this, it probably will signal the end of the America’s Cup as we know it,” Coutts is widely quoted as saying by the Associated Press.
Meanwhile, he’s checking out BMW/Oracle’s new multi-hull boat being built in Anacortes, Washington, home of the U. of Washington Huskies.
“I certainly wouldn’t be recommending that we challenge under such a one-sided set of rules,” he concluded.
His words have credibility. Previously, he sailed unbeaten through THREE straight America’s Cup matches, two for his native New Zealand, and one with Alinghi in 2003, before “a falling out” with Bertarelli.
He adds, needlessly, that the current rules tilt enormously toward Alinghi, the Defender.
Team New Zealand’s Grant Dalton, in yacht.com, has called for Alinghi and BMW/Oracle to negotiate a settlement right now.
He says that Alinghi’s successful appeal means the Cup reverts to the ground rules established by Alinghi and the Spanish “club” in 2007, when Alinghi beat Team NZ in the final leg in the final regatta by approximately an inch.
So, with one last appeal, BMW/Oracle continues its legal challenges against the Defender, a sailing team that beat (in come cases “slaughtered”) all previously contenders for the Cup, including the Americans, who managed to bomb out, on belief in their own press releases about how great they were, in the very first round of the Challenge eliminations.
As it now stands, Alinghi gets to choose the regatta judges, the committee to run it, the umpires and the measurers (and they must all be employees of Alinghi). All seven Challengers have opposed this “Alinghi Vision” of the next sham series or “stacked deck.”
Meanwhile, out on the water, Alinghi’s guys won the IShares Cup in Cowes, with a five-point lead over Team Origin, the British American Team. Oracle’s TWO Extreme 40 crews, Team Cammas and Team Spithill, finished fourth and fifth, respectively.
Wednesday, August 6, 2008
IS THE END NEAR?
Posted by
Stephen Bornet
at
12:38 PM
0
comments
Wednesday, July 30, 2008
QUESTIONS RAISED
With the latest court ruling, some immediate quesitons come to mind:
1. Will the catamaran challenge by BMW/Oracle be scrapped along with these hot boats?
2. Will Alinghi and its far-flung advertisers get "back aboard" for the next Cup event?
3. Will it be possible for the Alinghi folks to tread that fine line between gloating ("Told you so. Told you so!") and being just plain happy, to get things back on track quickly with a minimum of upset?
4. With the Challengers return "to the fold" and get their boats in the water, that is, off the drawing board and ready to race in 2009?
5. Will any new legal challenges be waged by BMW/Oracle to stall things again and again?
Anyone have any hints about this?
Posted by
Stephen Bornet
at
8:50 AM
0
comments
Labels: A FEW QUESTIONS
SNG Reinstated as Challenger of Record - - WOW
The New York Supreme Court has reinstated Club Náutico Español de Vela as the Challenger of Record, which had been challenged as "unfair" by BMW/Oracle in a legal challege last year.
The Appellate Division of the New York Supreme Court ruled in favour of the Société Nautique de Genève (SNG), declaring Club Náutico Español de Vela (CNEV) the rightful Challenger of Record for the 33rd America’s Cup and denying the Golden Gate Yacht Club (GGYC) this status.
Ernesto Bertarelli, Alinghi president, comments: “We are delighted with this result; we can now continue with our vision of a multi-challenger event. The court’s decision validates our actions and enables us to put the America's Cup back on the water.”
Lucien Masmejan, SNG lead counsel, comments: “After a year of litigation interference by the GGYC, we are extremely pleased that the Appellate Division has found its challenges to SNG's conduct of the 33rd America's Cup baseless. The GGYC’s actions have wasted a lot of time, effort and resources over the past year and we hope that it does not appeal. We must now evaluate whether adjustments have to be made due to the time consumed by its improper litigation initiatives.”
The decision of the Appellate Division reads: “…...the orders of the Supreme Court, New York County (Herman Cahn, J.), entered March 18, 2008 and May 13, 2008, which, inter alia, declared CNEV's challenge invalid and GGYC the Challenger of Record under the Deed of Gift, should be reversed, on the law, with costs, CNEV declared the Challenger of Record, and, in keeping with the Deed of Gift's requirement that the defender be given at least 10 months' written notice to prepare for the challenge, the 10-month notice period should be tolled until service of a copy of this order.”
Posted by
Stephen Bornet
at
8:45 AM
0
comments
Labels: MR. BERTARELLI PLEASED